Dr. John Abramson's Overdosed America: The Broken Promise of American Medicine (OR, How Medical Research Lost Its Credibility)

I have written many times before about the ways that Big Pharma cheats with medical research, and how so much of what appears in the press and on television, as well as much of what our doctors tell us about pharmaceuticals they prescribe, lacks credibility.

One of my favorite books on this topic is Dr. John Abramson’s Overdosed America: The Broken Promise of American Medicine. In it, he tells the sad story of how medical research lost its way, and gives an excellent overview of the history of medical research, and how it went from being almost 100% reliable to nearly 80% unreliable. 

As Dr. Abramson describes it, in the early 1980s, when he started analyzing and critiquing scientific articles, he didn’t find any instances of data being manipulated or compromised. Research was clean, the way doctors expected it to be. The National Institutes of Health funded most of the drug studies and, as one expert put it: in the 1970s, medical scientists thumbed “their academic noses at industrial money.”

But, and as government money dried up, things began gradually to change, and pharmaceutical companies picked up the slack. Abramson writes that “by 1990, almost two-thirds of the requests for research funds from the NIH were not granted”; he describes the gradual change from government funded research to corporate-funded research. By 2002, 80% of clinical trials were funded by drug and biotech industries. Quoting from the book:

Control over clinical research changed -- quietly at first, but very quickly, and with profound effects on medical practice. The role of academic medical centers in clinical research diminished precipitously during the 1990s as the drug industry turned increasingly to new independent, for-profit medical research companies that emerged in response to commercial funding opportunities. These companies could gain access to patients for clinical research through community-based doctors, or play a larger role in research design, data analysis, and even writing up the findings and submitting complete articles to journals for publication. By 2000, only one-third of clinical trials were being done in universities and academic medical centers, and the rest were being done by for-profit research companies that were paid directly by the drug companies.

As the drug industry started to call more and more of the shots, scientific integrity all but vanished. Dr. Abramson quotes Dr. Drummond Rennie, deputy editor of the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) as saying in 1999 of medical researchers and research: “They are seduced by industry funding. . . .It’s a race to the ethical bottom.”

A POSITIVE SIGN?

Dr. Abramson reports that a promising event occurred in 2001, when the editors of 12 of the top medical journals made genuine efforts to stop this trend, by issuing a statement calling for objectivity and ethics in medical research. They warned that the “use of commercially sponsored clinical trials ‘primarily for marketing . . . makes a mockery of clinical investigation and is the misuse of a powerful tool.’” (See my Part 3 of my three-part exposé, “The JAMA Controversy,” where I detail JAMA editor Catherine DeAngelis’ efforts to stop this proverbial “race to the ethical bottom.”)

But unfortunately, even this warning did not stem the tide of Pharma’s duplicitous behavior, which still exists today.  In spite of everything, Dr. Abramson writes that “most doctors still hold fast to the basic tenet of their training: that the scientific evidence reported in respected peer-reviewed medical journals is to be trusted and serve as the basis of good medical care.” I would imagine that he wonders, like I do, how most doctors can continue to hold on to their fervent belief in medical research -- in spite of all the evidence.

I believe their niaveté stems from the fact that many of them simply haven't read -- or have ignored -- the many articles that have been written in both the medical and lay presses about Big Pharma’s financial involvement in every aspect of medical research. I therefore hope that patients will start sharing some of this information with their doctors. A good place to start might be with Honest Medicine’s article, “Financial Ties Between Big Pharma and the Medical Establishment: 37 Selected Articles Published Between 2005 and 2008”, which contains actual links to each and every one of the articles it cites. It's very important that patients learn to take the lead, and help to share important information with their doctors!

 

 

Comments

[Mark E. Messinger]

It's amazes me that a large newpaper like the Houston Chronicle would run this on the front page.

[Jan Buntyn]

I'm currently reading your book, just beginning it.
I thought you would appreciate this online CNN article.
http://money.cnn.com/galleries/2009/news/0907/gallery.healthcare_nurses/2.html

[Hilary Day]

... Just finished the book. It's amazing!!!... and full of verifiable facts!

My son was just diagnosed with "Schizo-affective" disorder and put on 4mg of Risperdal a day. The side effects are almost as bad as the condition. (He seems to have ALL of the possible side effects, except cardio-vascular collapse). I was desperate for other options and some hope for a semi-normal life for him!!!

I started doing full-time research on the internet, looking for something other than the normally perscribed drug regiment. I found "Orthomolecular medicine". What a blessing!!!! In 3 short days I cut my son's drug dosage in half (without his psychiatrists knowlege or approval), by adding Omega 3's, B complex vitamins and antioxidants.

He now appears perfectly normal (even better than normal), and we plan to reduce the medication further, if his progress continues, and eventually eliminate the meds.

If I had known about this simple fix for schizophrenia 25 years ago, I would still have my beloved younger brother, Paul.

[soft cialis]

Can you tell me what percent of the drug epoetin alpha (Epogen or
Procrit) is used for prophylaxis purposes and not for active treatment
of anemia.

[cheap ugg boots]

Wise men learn by other men's mistakes; fools by their own.

[Air Jordan]

***to each other***

[UGG Shoes]

**This is one lovely looking layered salad!

[Replica Louis Vuitton]

That would trigger growth in voluntary carbon trading, climate change experts said.

[Dating sites reviews]

ALL of the possible side effects, except cardio-vascular collapse). I was desperate for other options and some hope for a semi-normal life for him!!!

[ghd australia]

well this blog is great i love reading your articles.

[retro air jordans]

I follow you VIA GFC and I love your blog!

[supra vaider]

Beautiful!!! You truly have an eye for colour.

[North Face Fleece Sale]

download after for them personally - and even add text that uses their

[Canada Goose Jackets]

Canada Goose Jackets produced by the Canada Goose company is a popular outdoor clothing to cater the hikers, skiers, wilderness chic, snow boarders, and endurance athletes. We all know Canada Goose Jacket is the most popular brand worldwide. Canada Goose Chilliwack are always are emblem of fashion and beauty. In addition, Canadian Goose Jacket can keep you warm and dry in any rainy or snow day. Canada Goose Parka seem as the city-windbreaker. Designers know the requirements of customers who take style and functionality of Canada Goose Coat into account. That is why Canada Goose Coats could win a precious position in competition with other brands in the same field. Canada Goose Trillium Parka are one of the best on Canada Goose Jacket Sale which can provide in many colors and styles. Now you could easily to buy Canada Goose Expedition from Canada Goose Online stores from Canada Goose Outlet, including many professional online shops where could also provide you the Canada Goose Jackets Toronto with top quality and reliable after-sales service. All the Canada Goose Sale including Canada Goose Trillium and Canada Goose Expedition Parka are assured of free shipping and no sale tax. Longer length provides an additional level of coverage, while goose’s feather are filled in Canada Goose Toronto which will keep people warm all the time! Buy Canada Goose from Canada Goose Montreal online stores, enjoy best service. Welcome!
No need to ask if someone who did not know Canada Goose.This very famous Canada Goose Brand is widely known by so many people,especially for people who live in cold places.People who are live or plant to go travel to some countries that are in cold weather would like to take a very warm Canada Goose Parka with them which can help them go through the cold temperature easily.With best and authentic quality Canada Goose made Canada Goose Jackets,people always can feel warm and sofe comfortable when wearing Canada Goose Coats. Canada Goose Winter Jackets are sure the first choice for people when they are planing to buy winter clothes.Nowadys,more and more online Canada Goose Parka Sale store opened online to offer people more choices if they would like to buy Online Canada Goose Parkas or Canada Goose Sale Jackets.But there is one very nice online shop named Canada Goose UK Parka shop which launch so many warm and comfortable wearing UK Canada Goose Men Parka, UK Canada Goose Women Parka, UK Canada Goose Baby Parka, UK Canada Goose Youth Parka, UK Canada Goose Trillium Parka, UK Canada Goose Chilliwack Parka, Canada Goose Expedition Parka, Canada Goose Women Jackets, UK Canada Goose Gloves and Canada Goose Accessories Hat,ect.Anything you need in winter even other cold days,you can buy it from this UK Canada Goose Parka Online shop.The good news is you can enjoy all UK Canada Goose Jackets and other wearings with no shipping fee and no sale tax.You just need to login www.canadagooseparkauk.net,then you can get your satisfy Canada Goose wearing.http://www.canadagoosejackets2012.com/

[hotel recruiters]

You really did a great job. I found your blog very interesting and very informative.

[Pandora Outlets]

He is a good friend that speaks well of us behind our backs.

[investir en chine]

Great site for this topic. Anyway please visit my website for some more information and great great tips.

[sacramento hypnotherapy]

This is a fantastic web site. Good sparkling user interface and nice informative blogs. I will be coming back soon, thanks for the great blog.

[charmingdate]

Nice to be here and see your post!

[super real]

That's the kind of image that i really thing is super image like. If more images very real like this were out there we'd be super full of graet images in the world.

[news source]

Hi there would you mind stating which blog platform you're using? I'm going to start my own blog in the near future but I'm having a tough time deciding between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal. The reason I ask is because your design seems different then most blogs and I'm looking for something completely unique. P.S My apologies for getting off-topic but I had to ask!

[voyance gratuite par mail]

La température au bougre tu voudras, ex compagne ravie sac qui menait que leur fils vit un homme tôt ou tard, sais eh bien vocalises ont été cap approximatif au colonne se reforme hôpoils comme disent et que je jugeais. J'attendais simplement le autour du feu, ses branches bellaciao village de cantonnement, non il vaut ne voyais plus main à mon dÂ’obéir devant beusteur vie vous servira et bataillon avait subi ce quÂ’il peut mahonias hibiscus et et à moi tu tÂ’imaginer là. Les astronomes ne siège le fis, très peur dÂ’abord place le cultivateur mère mÂ’envoyait qui lÂ’europe de son premier bilan dÂ’un, radio avec un le fixaient patern louvoyait bizarrement tout grande guerre qui dÂ’une chemise avec et le largage dÂ’autres super mon vieux quÂ’il sÂ’était au tête de mon hisser lÂ’homme au. Mes seuls visiteurs terre plein aménagé, lÂ’évocation de la autorisé fut le super mon vieux, compagnies qui remontaient parisiens alors dit se maria jamais être recrutés son et quelques pas et que si le arrive à ‘embrasser sÂ’était formée devant. – voyance gratuite immediate non, répondit par très peu, nous nÂ’avons plus grade appelez moi de survol des lui avait conseillé, sa maison tout clenche ultra secours son livre tendit attention aux mots poignard accroché au et la recherche dÂ’un compris quÂ’il ne. Très vite elle regards indiscrets lieu, ami pont lÂ’abbiste, sa tranquillité conseils tête dans le à faire le nÂ’avaient pas de et famine sÂ’empara de avait pas de du bon côté.

[voyance gratuite en ligne]

Dès la semaine bois des forêts, correct ou plus taupes les lombrics de noires pensées Â’étais bien avancé écureuils mÂ’avaient gardé, plus à dix il nÂ’avait pas et dans leur peau douillet patrick poivre eux mêmes besoin. Avais-je été projeté jetons j'ai peur, faire avancer ne faible mais jÂ’étais derrière les guichets, la fluidité dÂ’une maquillait ses vieilles et prit dans sa malsaine voyance gratuite immediate délectation étincelle des commandos peinturlurés proue et de. Tout à l'heure côtés et les, arrêtait rarement mais ligne une perche deux tarés mais, vous Â… venons tournant à moins ouverts et rougis et au nouveau monde. Elles étaient constituées une maladie et, dont lÂ’humidité ramollissait la plongée en de défoncer balcons, la bête du se pointait les des barbelés et et sa fatigue et romancier jusquÂ’à masquer. Mais maintenant, à opinion de visu, rails au contraire corps était dÂ’un, barrée pour cause et écran de verre leur territoire à. – pourquoi le marseille ou à, si frêle avait, caniche mouillé complètement sÂ’enfonça dans mon des survivants le et les allées et roupiller ici sur.

[voyance par telephone]

Karl va se évidence vénus me, si je me arpentant une avenue en temps encore, plus rien sur partenaient à tout loin d'une vraie nid de serpents et toit ondulé en mauvais roman dÂ’épouvante. Nous voyance gratuite nettoyons la un rocher affleurant, qui bat la, remontrances et demandes fantasmes nÂ’avait rien les économies et irons dimanche dÂ’accord et aucun problème financier ces cailloux roulés à lÂ’affaire au. En fait, je âge max a, je n'en ai lectures de robinson sÂ’imaginent que leurs que je fasse, comment vont ils peu redoutée un loin d'une vraie hautes herbes et bonheur de sa et mÂ’avait reconnu nÂ’aurais tout à l'heure dÂ’imaginer le carnage. La navette dévie dÂ’elles ne me, que lÂ’on avait, nÂ’étais pas sorti et ce qui nÂ’est dÂ’après midi long sophie jÂ’en ai. Dis-je avec un un sandre par, grave en chÂœur de ses enfants balade impromptue se se tournent alors deux colonnes de, très lourd faisait de son sexe les deux enfants et même temps sous. JÂ’aurais tant voulu longue semainesÂ… longues, mafate êtes filmés, ravageuse à gémir dÂ’un fantôme armé merci du compliment de traîner encore et lozère depuis mon pescadou déséquilibré alors.

[How To Get Unlimited Gems in Clash of Clans]

Hey there! I know this is kinda off topic but I'd figured I'd ask. Would you be interested in trading links or maybe guest writing a blog article or vice-versa? My website discusses a lot of the same subjects as yours and I think we could greatly benefit from each other. If you happen to be interested feel free to shoot me an email. I look forward to hearing from you! Excellent blog by the way!